Rapid East Manatee County Growth urges Moratorium Talk by Commission
7 mins read

Rapid East Manatee County Growth urges Moratorium Talk by Commission

Surrounded on overloaded roads and hurricane-flung homes, Manatee County Commissioners call local developers to the negotiating table to address rapid development in the East Manatee County with threats to introduce a building moratorium.

Commissioners then effectively defeated a controversial policy that in 2023 opened the door to Lakewood Ranch and several other masterpieces planned communities To develop further east in Manatee County, with plans to build tens of thousands of new houses on thousands of acres of land that were previously zoned for agriculture.

Politics allowed only developers of masterpiece planned to develop east of the county’s municipal service line if they met certain criteria. A previous board approved several projects consisting of more commissioners with favorable relationships with local developers.

An heated discussion about growth broke out during a public meeting in the Manatee County Commission last week. It culminated with a unanimous vote that led staff to take the necessary steps to formally remove policy with a future vote. It includes all public hearings and measures that are legally needed to make the change. Commissioners said they intend to deny all projects that are trying to use the policy in the meantime.

The subject of a moratorium was introduced by District 5 Commissioner Robert McCann, who mainly represents the Lakewood Ranch area. He is looking for a meeting with leading local developers Pat NealThe Rex Jensen and Carlos Bull.

“I want to reach out to all three (local developers) tomorrow and set up a meeting, if they want to meet,” McCann said last Tuesday. “If they do not want to meet, let me know. I actually want a meeting with all builders. I will start the discussion. We will see what they come to the table with, if we can work in collaboration.

Commissioner ZAP controversial foreseeing policy that enabled the development of East Manatee

The 2024 elections resulted in a resounding change in tenor on development from the county commission. Local developers who donate vigorously in the Manatee County election have maintained a favorable relationship with a majority of the board since the election 2020. But frustration over traffic jams, Floods in recent hurricanes and other development -related issues in East Manatee led to a change in representation.

Now three commissioners require a building moratorium intended to allow Manatee County to catch up with the necessary infrastructure improvements before they allow more development to continue.

McCann and co -commissioners Carol Felts and Jason Beaarden have sufficiently opposed the progress with development projects that were brought to the Board this year. McCann and Felts represent eastern and northern Manatee County, which have seen a significant development over the past decade is driven by the success of Lakewood Ranch.

The beard represents the county in general.

“This doesn’t work at all. I should warn others not to put the carriage in front of the horse,” McCann said. “Builders want to build houses. They want to put these houses before we have roads before we have taken care of storm water, before we even clean the river.”

The three commissioners have said that they intend to withstand further development approvals until traffic problems and other infrastructure needs have been resolved. They have carefully examined any development proposal that was brought to them this year, including final plates for development who have already received all other necessary approvals. But they have often fallen on 4-3 votes on these issues.

Developers have begun a lawyer for the process, which was previously handled as a routine through a “consent agenda”, together with other administrative approvals until this year.

Darin Parks, a lawyer at Grimes Galvano Law Firm, presented several plates for approval last Tuesday. He and other lawyers started most of these presentations by reminding commissioners that flat reviews are an approval confirming that they are following local and Florida teams.

“Unfortunately, our customers have to pay for our time to be here,” he said. “It is not insignificant to prepare for this in the unlikely case that there is a decision to deny the plates that follow the Florida Act and Manatee County Land Development Code.”

Political tension between commissioners arises over the development of East Manatee County

Early goodwill between new commissioners over the defeat for developer -friendly judges during the 2024 election slowly disappears over differences in political positions in development projects.

McCann spent much of the meeting by calling out the Voting record for District 3 commissioner Talha Siddique and the large commissioner George Kruse for votes in favor of development questions, which received heated response.

“I don’t read Facebook, but maybe you should,” McCann said. “Because they report to me what they put on Facebook and it is not favorable to many people. I will not try to call out any commissioner. I think decor is very important. But again I think truth and openness are very important.

But Siddique and Kruse said that Trio by commissioners have barked the wrong trees with a strong examination of plates and other development approval that meets all requirements. They also took problems with subsequent criticism for not following.

“What I have seen this board advocates for is functional legislation against a subset of this population,” Siddique said. “We must remember that infrastructure issues affect everyone here, and we must be a serious board that presents serious issues. Honestly, I do not hear that today with this moratorium discussion because the underlying needs are not raised.”

“I’m not for legislation and vote against plates because you want to stand on that hill,” he said. “You are welcome to, that’s good, but I don’t. I think there are other questions that we can certainly fight for the inhabitants of. Effects are one of them … We can do it as large -scale extensive plan text changes, Changes of Land Development Code. ”

Kruse, also frustrated with criticism, set his voting record straight. He has requested ways to deal with overload problems and put an end to the kind policy of the controversial developer for several years.

“In recent years, this board was far here, and I tried to get what I felt like sensible solutions to development,” Kruse said, gesting to the right and said he did not get support for his positions. “…. Now we start going the other way. At some point it is a good place to get to the middle.

“I’m not talking in Absolutes,” he said. “There are great things we can do. I think that’s how this board needs to go, and I think a moratorium is a bit absolute. I’m interested in hearing this conversation. I’m interested in hearing what solutions you came With Pat and Carlos and Rex, and I hope we come up with some good solutions.